The issue of tiers, Super 8’s, the Leinster Championship and Dublin have surfaced again after Dublin easily beat Meath in the Leinster final.
Some of the giants of football in Ireland fell at the weekend and throughout the championship so far, be it Donegal, Kerry, Tyrone and Cork for example.
But on the flip side, we’ve had the victories of Tipperary’s footballers while the hurlers lost out, and Cavan winning their Ulster Final.
It makes the championship more exciting having these new teams there and gives a huge amount of excitement to the counties and neutral observers too. There’s raw passion there for the game which was shown at the final whistle of the Munster and Ulster Finals, where as, and you can’t blame them, Dublin’s celebrations were routine, it was just another game to them.
The disappointing thing is that we expect Dublin to win the All Ireland Final even at this stage, and whoever they face in the Semi Final and final are going to get a pasting. Dublin do what Dublin do, they’re a well oiled machine, well drilled, experienced, but they didn’t wake up one morning and become that dominant team, there was tons of work involved and the buy in of all the players and the commitment that goes along with it.
People will resent the dubs for their dominance, but in any sport this can be the case, look at Formula One now with Lewis Hamilton winning his 7th World Championship, it happens, but it doesn’t mean there wasn’t hard work put in.
So, with all this talk and a strange season of club and championship where we’ve done things differently, is it time for the GAA to have a look at the layout of the championships, all of them, club, Leinster, county?
Lots of people seem to think so, former Carlow manager Turlough O Brien is one of them and has been against a tiered system from the outset.
On his twitter this weekend he said “Those results sent shock waves through the GAA! Cork out, Donegal out, Kerry out, Tyrone out… that’s the beauty of knockout.. we need to level the playing field not imbalance it further with Super 8s and tiers”.
He also spoke of his disappointment with Kildare and Meath who he feels are so much better than what they appear at the moment.
His solution to the championship is quite simple, he tweeted the following “Define the length of the inter county season & that dictates number of games; run league & championship concurrently in a condensed season. Magic!”
He wrote a long piece on this on his cycling website rotharroutes.com
Former Westmeath player John Connellan has been tweeting and has written an open letter on the what he calls is the perilous state of football in the province.
“A chairde,
“I am writing this open letter out of an abundance of concern for the game of football following the most recent mauling at the hands of Dublin of a proud county in the Leinster Championship.
“I will start this letter by saying that I am a huge admirer of Dublin. The work that has been done in the Capital over the last 20 years, on and off the field, has been immense and the Dubs are reaping the rewards of that human and financial investment.
“Dublin GAA is operating at an absolute optimal level on and off the field within the framework that the GAA has provided it, and that is all that any player/supporter can ask of their county board, team management and players. They deserve nothing other than enormous credit for that.
“Under the tenure of ex-President of the GAA, Sean Kelly (2003 – 2006), a committee was established to “rescue” the GAA within the Capital. Football and hurling were under threat from other sports, socio-economic factors, and a lack of investment in areas where the GAA was struggling to gain a foothold.
“In 2003, Dublin had not won a football All-Ireland since 1995 and had only won three of the previous ten Leinster titles. Following the formation of this committee and its ensuing work, Dublin from the years 2007 – 2017 received in the region of €16,612,847 in centrally-administered GAA coaching and games development funding. By contrast, the runners-up in last night’s Leinster Championship, Meath, during the same period received €822,647. My own county, Westmeath, received €725,501.
“Within this timeframe, Dublin GAA also managed to maximise its own commercial and marketing potential. In 2013, Dublin GAA announced its partnership with American insurer, AIG, which was understood to be valued at €800,000 per year for five years. In 2018, Dublin announced that this partnership was to be extended for a further five years for a figure in the region of €4million. That would equate to €8million over ten years. In March 2018, The Irish Times reported that Ballygowan and Britvic Ireland had renewed its three-year sponsorship with Dublin GAA, thought to be in the region of €350,000 over the following three years.
Among its other “official partners” which Dublin GAA lists on its website are O’Neill’s, Mitsubishi Motors, Intersport Elvery’s, Kinetica, The Gibson Hotel, and Gourmet Food Parlour.
“Of particular interest to the writer is that The Irish Times in February 2016, reported that Dublin GAA had chosen to remain with O’Neill’s as its official gear supplier for the following three years, despite huge interest from other manufacturers to secure the lucrative Dublin GAA supplier contract. The interest to the writer is, that in 2016, as a member of the Westmeath senior football team in advance of the Leinster final, I gladly and willingly together with all my teammates handed over €35 of my own money to pay for O’Neill’s leisure shorts that we could wear them on the bus to the final, rather than tracksuit bottoms given the warm summer we were having. I also note that one of the major challenges facing county boards across the country is kitting out their underage and senior teams year-in and year-out. It appears that while Dublin GAA has the marketing clout to attract significant financial offers from various competitors to supply their gear, other counties pay for the privilege.
“It is also noteworthy to see the commercial success of clubs within Dublin, none more noteworthy than Cuala GAA, who announced its partnership with biotech giants Amegen in 2019. It should also be noted that one of the largest expenses incurred by county boards is travelling expenses for its players and management teams. Dublin GAA does not have to incur this expense to a fraction of what other counties have to.
“None of the foregoing is to mention the obvious and natural advantage that Dublin’s ever-growing population provides. Aside from having a larger pool of players to pick from, this presents further financial advantages. One would think, given the amount of registered players in Dublin, that the ratio of coaching and games development funding allocated per registered played in Dublin would be lower than the other counties. However, that is not the case. Mayo GAA received approximately €22.30 per club registered player between 2010 and 2014 in coaching and games development money. Tyrone received €21 and Kerry €19. Dublin GAA received €270.70 per club-registered player during the same period. The figures for smaller counties within Leinster are not known to the writer.
“What Dublin have achieved with this allocation of GAA resources and its own marketing and commercial firepower is nothing short of phenomenal, and credit must be given. The committee formed under Sean Kelly as President of the GAA has more than achieved its objective of “rescuing” the GAA in the Capital, and sustainability has now been assured for our games in Dublin.
“Be it down to the success of the work of this committee, or any other factor, following last night’s triumph in the Leinster final, Dublin have now won 15 of the last 16 Leinster Championships and are chasing six in-a-row All-Irelands. An interesting statistic is that in Leinster Championship finals Dublin’s average winning margin over the last eight finals is 14.25 points. My own county’s experience of playing Dublin in championship football has yielded a 153-point losing margin over the last 12 games. As a competition, the Leinster Championship is broken and, this writer fears, beyond repair in its current form. It may be the case that, ultimately, drastic changes to the inter-provincial and All-Ireland structures, together with the fair allocation of resources, might not even be enough to bring football back from the brink. However, we must do something.
“The ultimate conclusion that I hope you can infer from the aforementioned is that Dublin GAA is now largely self-sustainable. It is on that basis that I would call on county boards across the country, but more immediately in Leinster, to demand a fair allocation of centrally-administered GAA resources. Leinster football is, to all intents and purposes, dead. It’s not dying. It is a once-great competition that can no longer be considered a viable entity due to Dublin’s dominance. The committee established under Sean Kelly recognised that the GAA in the Capital was under threat and it jumped to immediate and affirmative action. The GAA is failing to recognise, or is wilfully obtuse to the fact, that the GAA is, and has been, under serious threat in all of the other counties in Leinster for quite some time now. All we are asking is for the GAA to take the same action to address the threats faced by all the other counties outside the Capital which are every bit as important as those faced by Dublin GAA back in 2003.
“I call on county boards as representatives of the GAA in your counties to demand immediate action and parity. I call on players, and the GPA as the players’ representative body, to demand change. We are year-in and year-out sending hugely committed and talented footballers out to run in a race in which they are starting 200 metres behind the eventual winner, while on social media they are told to “train harder” and “believe more”. We all owe current and future players, and supporters, a duty of care to address the inequity which has been created, and to bring meaningful proposals to the GAA on how to address these inequities. Players across the country under the current status quo are being robbed of meaningful inter-county careers. As a GAA community, our inaction is failing them.
“I would encourage all of the county boards in Leinster to come together and discuss potential proposals to bring to the GAA. I believe that we must all be united on this front if we are to cause the GAA to take any meaningful action. Failing the GAA’s agreement to make significant changes, I would encourage county boards to stop the practice of sending players, who give so much to the cause of their counties, to compete in a competition where they are set up to fail. The GAA have too much to lose through TV image rights etc not to listen. Instead, invest the monies allocated to prepare your teams for the Leinster Championship in competing to the highest level in your respective leagues. Invest in your Club Championship, which this summer has shown to be the jewel in the GAA’s crown.
“Unfortunately, I’m of the view, given the perilous state of the Leinster Championship and Leinster Council, and the GAA’s failure to act heretofore, that drastic action such as that suggested might be the only way we can achieve equality in how our games are being run and administered.”
Mise le meas,
John Connellan
Concerned Gael
If, after last night’s Leinster Final you’re as concerned about football as I am then you might want to give this open letter a read and tag your county’s twitter pages. @officialgaa @gaelicplayers @westmeath_gaa @MeathGAA @KildareGAA @OfficialLDGAA @wicklowgaa @ShaneSaint pic.twitter.com/zOhhyVvhQW
— John Connellan (@johnC_BL) November 22, 2020
What are your thoughts, let us know in the comments section.
